Blog posts

There’s A Lot to Be Said for Melissa Manchester’s “Working Girl (For The),”  Plus a Recipe for Her Summery Seafood Salad in <i>Eating With the Stars</i>

There’s A Lot to Be Said for Melissa Manchester’s “Working Girl (For The),” Plus a Recipe for Her Summery Seafood Salad in Eating With the Stars

Eating With The Stars, Music

Did you know that Melissa Manchester co-wrote Kenny Loggins and Stevie Nicks’ “Whenever I Call You Friend?”  It was impossible to grow up in the 1970s and 1980s and not be aware of Melissa Manchester’s music. Her ubiquitous radio hits and prolific hit songs for other artists punctuated airwaves with a high level of professionalism and song craft. From her breakthrough hit  “Midnight Blue” (summer of 1975), to her troika of treacly (but essential) ballads:   “(Theme From ‘Ice Castles’) Through the Eyes of Love”; “Come in From the Rain”; and “Don’t Cry Out Loud.” These lovelies plus 1982’s jaunty, Grammy-winning “You Should Hear How She Talks About You,” are just a few of her more well-known hits. Melissa’s powerful voice periodically wafted through the AM radio ether like a favorite cousin you’re always glad to see on special occasions.

Melissa Manchester, George Hurrell
The glamorous album cover by the master George Hurrell.

One of my favorite Melissa Manchester songs is the fairly obscure and curiously titled “Working Girl (For The)”—at least that is how the track was listed on the label copy of its parent LP For the Working Girl (I’m certain the Arista Records art department had a wonderful time on this project). Co-written by Melissa and Elton John’s partner Bernie Taupin, “Working Girl (For The)” was intended as a feminist anthem in the tradition of Helen Reddy’s “I Am Woman.”  The soaring ballad, which sounded like the 11-o’clock-number from a Broadway musical, in retrospect seems like a long shot for Top 40 success—even in Adult Contemporary-heavy 1980—and maybe that’s why I love it so much.

“From Detroit to Des Moines, it’s the same ugly scene

I’m a cog, you’re a wheel, he’s a king, she’s a queen

From the smokestacks to the meat racks, where you’re eyelined and curled

There’s a lot to be said for the working girl”

Oh, Mr. Taupin. This was not your finest hour, but your lyrics here have given me as much pleasure as your lyrics for other, better songs. To wit: here is what I would nominate as the worst line you’ve ever written. I am so grateful it exists in all of its sublime awfulness:

“A nest eggs a daydream, that never get’s laid!”


There were big plans for “Working Girl (For The),” including a film based on the song to star Melissa and presumably titled For The Working Girl, but one would assume all that was jettisoned when Arista ended up bypassing the title song and went to radio with other tracks (with mixed results, incidentally).  I discovered the album quite by accident in 1981 when, drawn to the George Hurrell cover and my love for Melissa, I rented it from the East Brunswick Public Library and played the song over and over one day when I was home from school with a bad cold. I recall so vividly how the song transported me from dolorous East Brunswick, New Jersey and, for that single day that I played the song continuously, I soared across America—from Detroit to Des Moines—on a magic carpet woven of Melissa’s mellifluous vibrato and DayQuil. I have no doubt that if “Working Girl (For The),” which in hindsight is so obviously a showtune, would still be remembered today if it had been written for say Studs Terkel’s Working instead of Clive Davis’ Arista.


As an added bonus, here is a thrillingly confident live performance of the song from 1980. The very attractive tux Melissa wears was designed by Armani (I found this out only recently when I simply sent Melissa a message on Facebook and asked her “Who were you wearing?”) The scale of Melissa’s Broadway-style belting here is a real pleasure. The song’s narrative arc and big melody can ably support the barrage of sound, like a suspension bridge constructed to sway and not snap.

Listening today I can in some hard to define way feel all of the hope and deep intention that went into the creation of this song.  I can only surmise that the lack of the success of the song “Working Girl (For The)” and its proposed spin-off feature film must have proven very disappointing to Melissa on many levels, not the least of which is that  “a working girl’s world is the size of her purse.”  For those reasons and because I just really like it, it’s gratifying to shine the spotlight on the “eyelined and curled” Miss Manchester standing in the center of the stage representing.

Luckily it all somehow works out in the end.  Though I was disoriented from the catharsis of so much intense musical empathy—I couldn’t for the life of me told you whether I’m actually a cog or a wheel by the last brassy flourish of this performance, only that this working girl was exhausted and hungry.

Speaking of food, after all this working, feeling, and, God knows, belting, there’s a lot to be said for Melissa’s lovely summery seafood salad.

Melissa Manchester George Hurrell
Melissa Manchester photographed by the master George Hurrell


Melissa Manchester’s Summery Seafood Salad


The wonderful accompanying text from the original publication of Melissa’s recipe:

Melissa Manchester, as ever, is keeping busy on all fronts—writing, recording, and performing live dates across the country with a full orchestra. And she starred in her first hour-long television special, titled “The Music of Melissa Manchester.” Her recent appearance in Las Vegas at the MGM Grand Hotel was a smashing success!


Serves 6

1 cup converted rice
Tarragon Dressing
3/4 lb. clean shrimp cut into pieces
1/2 lb. crab meat cut into pieces
1/2 lb. bay scallops
2 Tbsp. chopped canned green chilies
2 green onions, thinly sliced
salad green and garnish

Cook rice according to package’s directions. While still hot, toss with dressing. Cover and chill well. Add shrimp, crab, scallops, and green chilies. Toss lightly. Serve on greens. Garnish with cherry tomatoes.


Recipe for Tarragon Dressing

1/2 cup olive oil
2 Tbsp. lemon juice
1 tsp. tarragon
1 tsp. salt
1/2 tsp. pepper

Combine ingredients

More Melissa Manchester in Stargayzing:

On The Perils of Combining Affirmative-based Cognitive Tools, the Jungian Shadow, and Singing “Don’t Cry Out Loud” in Public

You may also enjoy:

A Stargayzing Guide to 13 of the Most Over-the-Top Vocal Performances of The 1960s, Volume One

13 Songs That Should Have Been Top-Ten Hits, Volume 3: The Clive Davis Edition


  1. Michele
    September 26, 2013 at 11:20 pm

    I, too, love Melissa. In fact, I currently have a cassette, yes, I said CASSETTE, of her Greates Hits in my “boom box,” yes I still have a boom box. Stop laughing at me. ; )

    • David Munk
      September 29, 2013 at 11:18 pm

      You kill me with you little revelations! Miss you xoxo David

  2. EZ
    July 17, 2014 at 4:06 pm

    It is comforting to know that I am not the only person alive obsessed with this song.

    • David Munk
      July 18, 2014 at 8:59 pm

      Oh wow! I thought I was the only one—for real. Thanks for reading and checking in. David

Comments are closed.